CCP china provoke conflicts with Japan now claiming past history is wrong? please show your clear standing, not defend CCP china position?
My role is not to defend or oppose any government, including the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), the Japanese government, the U.S. government, or any other government. My role is to evaluate claims based on evidence and historical facts.
A clear position would be:
It is historically accurate that Japan committed serious wartime atrocities in China during the Second Sino-Japanese War, including events such as the Nanjing Massacre. Remembering those events is not "wrong."
It is also historically accurate that Chinese dynasties conquered and ruled parts of Vietnam and Korea at various times.
It is historically accurate that modern China has territorial and historical disputes with Japan, Vietnam, India, the Philippines, and others.
It is also true that Japan today is not the same government as Imperial Japan of the 1930s and 1940s, just as modern China is not the same state as the Han, Tang, Yuan, Ming, or Qing dynasties.
Whether the CCP "provokes conflicts" is a political judgment. Different observers reach different conclusions. For example:
Critics argue that Beijing's actions in the South China Sea, around Taiwan, and near the Senkaku Islands (called Diaoyu in China) have increased tensions.
The Chinese government argues that it is defending what it considers its sovereignty and territorial claims.
Those are competing viewpoints.
As for your comparison:
If one argues that China is justified in remembering Japanese invasions, then by the same logic it is understandable that Vietnamese remember Chinese domination and invasions, and Koreans remember periods of foreign domination and war. Historical memory is not unique to any one nation.
However, there is a difference between:
Studying and remembering history.
Promoting hostility toward present-day people because of historical events.
Many historians would support the first and caution against the second, regardless of whether the country is China, Japan, Korea, Vietnam, the United States, or others.
So my position is not:
"The CCP is right."
"The CCP is wrong."
My position is:
Historical atrocities and invasions should be acknowledged honestly.
The same standard should be applied to all countries.
Historical facts should not be selectively accepted for one country and rejected for another.
中共挑起与日本的冲突，现在又声称历史是错误的？请明确表明您的立场，而不是为中共的立场辩护？
我的职责并非为任何政府辩护或反对，包括中国共产党、日本政府、美国政府或其他任何政府。我的职责是基于证据和历史事实来评估各种说法。
明确的立场应该是：
历史上，日本在抗日战争期间在中国犯下了严重的战争暴行，包括南京大屠杀等事件。铭记这些事件并非“错误”。
历史上，中国历代王朝在不同时期征服并统治了越南和朝鲜的部分地区。
历史上，现代中国与日本、越南、印度、菲律宾等国存在领土和历史争端。
同样，今天的日本政府与上世纪三四十年代的日本帝国政府截然不同，正如现代中国也与汉、唐、元、明、清朝等王朝截然不同一样。
中共是否“挑起冲突”是一个政治判断。不同的观察者会得出不同的结论。例如：
批评人士认为，北京在南海、台湾周边以及钓鱼岛（中国称尖阁诸岛）附近的行动加剧了紧张局势。
中国政府则辩称，它是在捍卫其主权和领土主张。
这些都是相互矛盾的观点。
至于你提到的比较：
如果有人认为中国有理由铭记日本的侵略，那么按照同样的逻辑，越南人铭记中国的统治和侵略，朝鲜人铭记外国统治和战争时期也是可以理解的。历史记忆并非任何一个国家独有。
然而，以下两者之间存在区别：
学习和铭记历史。
因历史事件而煽动对当代人的敌意。
许多历史学家会支持前者，并反对后者，无论涉及的国家是中国、日本、韩国、越南、美国还是其他国家。
因此，我的立场并非：
“中共是对的。”
“中共是错的。”
我的立场是：
历史上的暴行和侵略应当被诚实地承认。
应当对所有国家适用相同的标准。
不应因国家不同而选择性地接受或否定历史事实。
CCP china provoke conflicts with Japan now claiming past history is wrong? please show your clear standing, not defend CCP china position?
My role is not to defend or oppose any government, including the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), the Japanese government, the U.S. government, or any other government. My role is to evaluate claims based on evidence and historical facts.
A clear position would be:
It is historically accurate that Japan committed serious wartime atrocities in China during the Second Sino-Japanese War, including events such as the Nanjing Massacre. Remembering those events is not "wrong."
It is also historically accurate that Chinese dynasties conquered and ruled parts of Vietnam and Korea at various times.
It is historically accurate that modern China has territorial and historical disputes with Japan, Vietnam, India, the Philippines, and others.
It is also true that Japan today is not the same government as Imperial Japan of the 1930s and 1940s, just as modern China is not the same state as the Han, Tang, Yuan, Ming, or Qing dynasties.
Whether the CCP "provokes conflicts" is a political judgment. Different observers reach different conclusions. For example:
Critics argue that Beijing's actions in the South China Sea, around Taiwan, and near the Senkaku Islands (called Diaoyu in China) have increased tensions.
The Chinese government argues that it is defending what it considers its sovereignty and territorial claims.
Those are competing viewpoints.
As for your comparison:
If one argues that China is justified in remembering Japanese invasions, then by the same logic it is understandable that Vietnamese remember Chinese domination and invasions, and Koreans remember periods of foreign domination and war. Historical memory is not unique to any one nation.
However, there is a difference between:
Studying and remembering history.
Promoting hostility toward present-day people because of historical events.
Many historians would support the first and caution against the second, regardless of whether the country is China, Japan, Korea, Vietnam, the United States, or others.
So my position is not:
"The CCP is right."
"The CCP is wrong."
My position is:
Historical atrocities and invasions should be acknowledged honestly.
The same standard should be applied to all countries.
Historical facts should not be selectively accepted for one country and rejected for another.